17勛圖厙

Skip to main content

The Fight to End Deepfake Intimate Image Abuse: Case Studies from the US and UK

By Tina Yong


Deepfake pornography is a form of non-consensual intimate image (NCII) abuse which involves hyperrealistic depictions of individuals (most often
) in little to no clothing and/or performing sexually explicit acts. The spread of nonconsensual deepfakes has been understood to be a particularly intractable problem for regulators due to the fact that such material is often shared anonymously on obscure online forums, in addition to the sheer volume of content being made created and distributed (a 2023 report observes that are pornographic in nature).

The United States and United Kingdom are two countries which have passed federal legislation on deepfake NCII in recent years. This article will compare their respective regulatory frameworks and conclude by highlighting where each country is falling short in resolutely putting an end to the proliferation of sexually explicit deepfakes. 

U.K. 

The first comprehensive legislation on sexually explicit deepfakes across the UK came in October 2023 with the passing of the , which — among other things — expanded pre-existing definitions of a sexual offence to include the act of sharing NCII, both real and synthetic. In June of 2025, an amendment made to the Data (Use and Access) Act heeded to by criminalizing the creation of deepfake NCII (in addition to its distribution). However, the law was , having come into force in February 2026, more than six months after it received royal assent. After a slew of incidents involving , Prime Minister Keir Starmer pledged to hold technology firms responsible for removing NCII from their platforms , calling it a “national emergency.” This measure is expected to be put into place in the fall. 

U.S. 

The “,” passed in May of 2025, criminalized the publication of deepfake NCII federally and superseded the patchwork of local regulations pertaining to deepfakes. In addition to making it a criminal offense to distribute non-consensually produced “digital forgeries,” the Act requires tech firms to remove explicit deepfake material from its sites within 48 hours of it being reported. The Federal Trade Commission one year after its passage, and criminal convictions have been made in its name. 

Legislative gaps 

One notable similarity between the evolution of deepfake law in the US and UK is that both governments tended to invest greater attention to the publication of deepfake NCII, rather than its creation and possession. Only in the last year did the UK government make creation a criminal offence, after scholars and advocates criticized the Online Safety Act for . On this front, the US is lagging behind, as it has yet to pass any federal law prohibiting the creation of deepfake NCII for private use, which could look like banning nudification apps and demanding that AI companies block users from generating “NSFW” content. 

Despite the slightly more robust approach taken by the UK, the legislative response to the flood of deepfake NCII has been slow-going in both countries, with countless victims having suffered the cost of regulatory inertia. Both countries’ emphasis on establishing mechanisms for requesting take-down — while well-intentioned — are ultimately inadequate because many victims do not know when their images have been used and circulated, or because the damage may already be done by the time the material is removed. Criminal laws offer a more promising avenue towards deterrence and legal recourse for victims, but they may be vulnerable to the “free speech” defense, since deepfakes contain an expressive element and . Additionally, a showed that deepfake NCII proved resilient to regulatory and platform shocks, showing no overall decrease in prevalence after the passage of the TAKE IT DOWN Act. 

In general, there is a lack of sustained funding for research and policy experimentation when it comes to tackling NCII, leaving states and local authorities with few tools in the chest and having to resort to the same interventions that have proven to be ineffective. What’s currently missing from the picture may be a keen attention to the social ethics and psychology behind the allure of pornography, as well as what kind of cultural shift is needed to make the online world permanently safer for women and girls, which could start with reforms in sex education and mental health services. We should also understand this phenomenon of NCII as one that is thoroughly steeped in the politics of gender and therefore not only a matter of balancing competing interests, but of meeting the state’s guarantee of equality before and under the law. 

Deepfakes are a novel problem that will require novel solutions; it is a good thing that lawmakers are beginning to take NCII seriously, but much swifter and more creative action will be needed to root out what is indeed a persistent — but not ineradicable — problem.

Tina Yong

Tina Yong

Tina Yong is a PhD student in the Political Science Department at the University of Toronto. Her research sits at the intersection between AI ethics and legal theory, specifically free speech jurisprudence as it applies to AI-generated content. Her work centers on the substantive equality approach to freedom of expression pioneered by Catharine MacKinnon and its contemporary relevance for the regulation of deepfake pornography. She is broadly interested in the gendered implications of generative AI tools and the law's capacity to address the rise of non-consensual sexual material.